House Joint Committee Hears Medical Aid in Dying Bill

Feb 27, 2018

House Judiciary Committee chair, Scott Nishimoto (left) and Health and Human Services chair, John Mizuno, heard nearly one hundred testifiers on House Bill 2739
Credit Wayne Yoshioka

The House Health and Human Services and Judiciary Committees heard public testimony today on medical aid in dying legislation. HPR’s Wayne Yoshioka reports.

 

 

Dr. Peter Barcia opposes HB 2739
Credit Wayne Yoshioka

House Bill 2739 would provide terminally ill, mentally capable patients, the option of requesting licensed physicians to prescribe them medication to end their lives.  Dr. Peter Barcia, a surgeon for 51 years, testified against the measure.

 

“What it does is, it takes the care-giving physician, which I was trained to become, and makes them a killer.  I mean, I find that absolutely repulsive.”

 

The bill contains safeguards, including written documentation, physician and witness confirmations, extended waiting periods and patient cancellation.  The measure would also impose criminal charges for abuse, tampering or patient coercion.  Dr. Ron Hart, supports the bill, and says it’s not the act but the choice that matters.

 

Dr. Ron Hart supports HB 2739
Credit Wayne Yoshioka

“A good case can be made that medical aid in dying should be looked at in the frame of human rights and civil liberties.  We believe very deeply in the principle of liberty and self-determination.”

 

As currently written, physician participation would be voluntary and the prescribed drugs would be self-administered or ingested by the terminally ill patient.   But, Dr. Craig Nakatsuka, a hospice physician, says having the drugs readily available is problematic.

 

Dr. Craig Nakatsuka opposes HB 2739
Credit Wayne Yoshioka

“Having in the medicine cabinet 100 bright orange capsules of Secobarbital, the preferred drug for lethal ingestion, is an open invitation for accidental or intentional overdose.”

 

The Senate passed a similar medical aid in dying measure last session and the governor has indicated he would sign the current bill into law.  But, House Health and Human Services Committee Chair, John Mizuno, says a decision on the bill must be weighed in light of 13-hundred submitted testimonies.

 

“After talking with the chairs and the vice chairs, we decide to hold decision-making tomorrow, Wednesday, February 28th, 12 noon, in room 329.”

 

Legislative Lobbyist and terminal cancer patient John Radcliffe says the bill should become law.
Credit Wayne Yoshioka

But, Legislative Lobbyist and terminal cancer patient, John Radcliffe, who also testified, says he believes lawmakers will pass the bill.

 

“Anybody who was opposed to death with dignity shouldn’t be afraid of this law.  This is even stronger than any other laws there are as far as I can tell.  But, nonetheless, it’s the best we’re gonna get so I’m for it.”

 

For HPR News, I’m Wayne Yoshioka.